How do you fix the Dawlish problem?

Railway workers inspect the main Exeter to Plymouth railway line that has been closed due to parts of it being washed away by the sea at Dawlish, Devon Repairs are getting under way, but will they be enough in the longer term?

Related Stories

It is not the first time the powers of nature have brought a halt to railway services running through the Devonshire seaside town of Dawlish, but many are saying it should be the last.

This week, what some have long predicted came true as huge waves uprooted and washed away great chunks of track and brought parts of the sea wall crashing down.

Over the next six weeks, work is to be carried out on this precarious section of a vital rail line that connects Devon and Cornwall to the rest of the UK.

Will this just be a sticking plaster or is the answer now to move the line inland?

Transport Secretary Patrick McLoughlin has said he will conduct a "rigorous review" of alternative rail routes to the South West of England.

Some warn it will take too long and prove too expensive to reroute this coastal section of the railway line, built by Isambard Kingdom Brunel in Victorian times.

Robin Gisby, managing director of network operations at Network Rail, says there needs to be a longer-term look at the line, however - something many rail experts are calling for.

GWR route map, 1930s A Great Western Railway map from the 1930s shows just how many miles of track once criss-crossed Devon and Cornwall.

One of the solutions could involve taking a step back in time and reinstating the old Tavistock line.

Until 1968, following cuts approved by chairman of the British Transport Commissioner Richard Beeching, it was possible to travel from Exeter to Plymouth via Okehampton and Tavistock on a double-tracked line. Part of it still runs as the Dartmoor Railway, which runs special services on weekends, bank holidays and school holidays.

Halted by Hitler

Another possibility could involve rerouting trains along the former Teign Valley branch line, which ran inland from Exeter before rejoining the main line at Newton Abbot. Substantial work would be needed to restore the line, which closed in 1958.

Map: Alternative routes west

Alternatively, rail chiefs could revisit a scheme to build an entirely new route which Hitler inadvertently put paid to.

Start Quote

If you close it completely, you're losing a piece of glorious railway”

End Quote Sim Harris Railnews

Sim Harris, managing editor of industry newspaper Railnews, explained that rerouting the line along an existing route, would be "highly feasible", but trains would have to change direction at Exeter and Plymouth, causing delays.

"There is another solution, which would have been ideal if Hitler had not got in the way," said Mr Harris. "Before the last war, the Great Western Railway bought some land, inland, between Newton Abbot and Exeter, which would have been splendid. But before they could actually do the work, war broke out. As it was nationalised after the war, the land was sold off again.

"So if it hadn't been for Hitler, we would have had that route - but that's history, and that's how it happened.

He suggests revisiting that scheme by buying a strip of land and building a new double-track railway.

The Dawlish line could then be kept as a single track serving coastal communities, but mainline services would run on the new line.

Analysis

If the transport secretary needed any reminding of how the sea washed away one of his train lines, the waves came back to make their presence felt. As Patrick McLoughlin addressed the media, they rose up beside him, crashing against the station in Dawlish.

One railway worker told me the pounding earlier this week had caused the whole platform to shift. Services can't get in or out even if the track was mended, he told me, although there was no official confirmation of this additional insight.

Despite the high tide, the weather was pleasant, for a change. The sun shone on the minister and the backdrop was blue. The town had gone from picture of disaster to picturesque once again.

Men in orange jackets wandered up and down the track assessing the damage and all in the shadow of the mightiest of engineers but the mightiest of seas too. It could be six weeks before part of Brunel's legacy is restored.

Whether the future holds an alternative - less exposed - route in and out of a remote part of the England, Mr McLoughlin was giving nothing away. But he did recognise the romance of the old line.

And it will need all the love it can get as the weather turns once again.

"If you close it completely, you're losing a piece of glorious railway - and places like Teignmouth and Dawlish would lose their local service," he added.

Transport infrastructure expert John Disney of Nottingham Business School said Dawlish was "an accident waiting to happen".

"It was entirely predictable that at some time the sea was going to win the 'Battle of Dawlish' and sweep away Brunel's coastline railway," he said. "It is amazing that it has lasted until 2014, due mainly to Network Rail's excellent infrastructure maintenance regime."

Looking to the future, he said that reopening and modernising the inland line through Okehampton should be considered.

Five-year project

Dr Disney said: "Long-term serious consideration must now be given to reopening an alternative inland railway line through Devon closed during the Beeching era.

"While local campaigners have been fighting for this restoration for some time, there has been little Westminster support but the tide may now be turning."

Dr Disney estimated rerouting would take five years. Using existing track would be an obvious solution - but upgrading work would have to be carried out, he added.

"When we look at current rail projects, it's not inconceivable," he said. "It wouldn't be anything like as difficult as the Crossrail project in London and wouldn't be controversial like HS2."

Too important

Transport commentator Christian Wolmar said: "I think it's time to build a new railway and ultimately this will be clear.

Start Quote

If this was the main line to Guildford, it would have been done a long time ago”

End Quote Christian Wolmar Transport commentator

"I suspect the best thing is to reroute the train line through Tavistock and keep a single line through Dawlish.

"This is likely to happen again - we're getting one-in-a-hundred-year storms every year. Of course they have to repair it this time but it's too important a link for Cornwall.

"If this was the main line to Guildford, it would have been done a long time ago."

Speculating on the figures involved, he added: "If this is going to cost £50m to fix, you might as well spend £250m on building new track. In the long run, it will save money."

In 2011 when creating an alternative line was mooted, then-environment minister Lord Henley suggested it would cost £100m. He rejected this as being "far too expensive", however.

Holiday trade

Richard Clinnick, assistant editor at Rail magazine, said: "It's a situation now where this is something that seriously, seriously needs to be looked at. We could have another situation like the one we have at the moment, where Devon and Cornwall is cut off.

"There has been talk of doing away with the Dawlish line, but you can't do that. The line that is currently severed covers Dawlish and Teignmouth - and importantly, it also covers Torquay and Paignton, which are huge for the holiday trade."

With so many experts having apparently foreseen Dawlish's fate, the government will know it has some tough decisions to make about its future.

In the meantime, rail engineers will try to get trains moving again, while businesses in the region see millions of pounds of income disappear each day and rail travellers face ongoing disruption.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More UK stories

RSS

Features

  • Witley Court in Worcestershire Abandoned mansions

    What happened to England's lost stately homes?


  • Tray of beer being carried10 Things

    Beer is less likely to slosh than coffee, and other nuggets


  • Spoon and buckwheatSoul food

    The grain that tells you a lot about Russia's state of mind


  • Woman readingWeekendish

    The best reads you need to catch up on


  • Salim Rashid SuriThe Singing Sailor

    The young Omani who became a prewar fusion music hit


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.