A Point of View: Has the Catholic Church really changed?

A woman holding rosary beads

Pope Francis has made moves towards reform - but can he overcome a bedrock of opposition, asks Sarah Dunant.

Looking back on it I think I was about 10 or 11 when the sacrament of confession worked best for me. I have vivid memories of a sense of burden as I entered the confessional box. Had I remembered all the things I'd done wrong? Was I truly sorry for them? Equally powerful was the relief that came upon me afterwards. Penance was never hard - a few Hail Marys next to a colourful statue of the Virgin crushing a snake underfoot - and walking home everything seemed suddenly brighter. I was forgiven, absolved. The world, and I inside it, felt new again.

I have been revisiting that feeling as I watch the titanic struggle now going on within the Catholic Church, a Church which I left in my late teens, committed by then to a different kind of new world.

Pope Francis's calls for mercy, forgiveness and a priesthood truly at the service of the laity is at the heart of a reform that, if successful, could transform the nature of Catholicism as we know it. It's as if the Church - the institution itself - is being asked to enter the confessional, acknowledging its sins in readiness for a new start.

Find out more

Sarah Dunant
  • Sarah Dunant is a writer, broadcaster and critic
  • A Point of View is usually broadcast on Fridays on Radio 4 at 20:50 GMT and repeated Sundays, 08:50 GMT

Though communism and Catholicism have little in common one can't help but find it reminiscent of the perestroika moment when Gorbachev opened up a closed corrupt system for reform.

Both systems, one might argue, had become unfit for purpose. In the case of the Catholic Church, the long pontificate of John Paul II with his charisma and popularity obscured this reality, shielding entrenched financial corruption and a hierarchy increasingly out of step with the modern world, though not even he could ignore the gathering tsunami of sexual abuse and cover-up. As the scale of the problem emerged, Europe in particular suffered. Recruitment to the priesthood and closed orders dropped radically. Over the last 15 years in Ireland, Spain and especially in Italy (where I work part of the time), churches seemed to grow bigger as congregations grew smaller. And older - the dwindling of numbers a particular problem when it comes to women who, ironically given their lack of power, have traditionally kept the flame alive in the family. Worldwide, the numbers of Catholics may still look healthy, but in Europe, the centre of its history and government, there is clearly a crisis.

A general view of St. Peter's Square during the John Paul II Beatification Ceremony held by Pope Benedict XVI on May 1, 2011 in Vatican City

If that old adage learning from history has any meaning, one can only look in awe to another historical parallel, this one within the Church itself 500 years ago.

Start Quote

In the real world, Francis' milder reforms have already hit a bedrock of opposition”

End Quote

The sins around 1515 were largely the same - humanity remains fond of two in particular - fornication and avarice. Popes had children, cardinals had mistresses, priests had housekeepers, monks occasionally had each other and childhood, which effectively ended at 12 or 13, was fair game to those in power whatever their proclivity.

Financial corruption was systemic. Palaces, parties, patronage - the use of Church money to feather the nests of those working for it makes the recent scandal of the German bishop with his 15,000-euro bath tub look like a visit to Homebase. Looking back on it now you might argue that part of that outrageous wealth went into great art; stand in the middle of the Sistine Chapel and weigh up charity against beauty. The truly egregious fault was less what they did with it than how they got it - selling indulgences and auctioning offices in an ever-expanding bureaucracy.

Carlo Maria Martini Carlo Maria Martini was critical of the church's attitude to sexuality and contraception

Then, as now, there were voices pushing for reform. The Church has always had a strong pull towards the Franciscan vision - poverty and humility against ceremony and authority. Years before the election of our modern Pope Francis, Carlo Maria Martini, cardinal and archbishop of Milan, was openly critical of the Church's stance on sexuality and contraception. In a final interview before his death in 2012 he called for a radical transformation, beginning with the pope and his bishops. Pope Benedict did not attend his funeral. Meanwhile in America, nuns were devoting more of their time to pastoral and social work outside the cloisters, only to find themselves under papal investigation to root out "certain radical feminist themes incompatible with the Catholic faith".

Francis's election in March 2013 took place 500 years almost to the day after that of Leo X. Son of Lorenzo de Medici and a career churchman (he was cardinal at 18), his comment on winning - accurate in spirit if not his actual words - was "since God has given us the papacy, let us enjoy it". So the pope "fiddled" as Rome started to burn.

Martin Luther Martin Luther ignited reform, and the Catholic Church responded

The spark of course came from Germany four years later when the Augustinian Martin Luther took reform into his own hands. Among the many broadsides he launched, perhaps the most significant in terms of the crisis today was against celibacy (he went on to marry a nun). The Catholic Church's response through the counter-reformation was retrenchment. The doctrine of celibacy - singleness and sexual purity - would continue.

Fast forward to October 2015, when the Polish priest and theologian Krzysztof Charamsa, gay and proud with his partner, left the curia by means of a press conference on the eve of the family synod, accusing the Church of hypocrisy and homophobia. Who could doubt his honesty? Or the viper's nest of infighting it revealed inside the Vatican?

Monsignor Krzysztof Charamsa, second secretary of the Vatican's International Theological Commission, with his partner Eduard leaves after a press conference in Rome, Italy, 03 October 2015 Monsignor Krzysztof Charamsa (left, with his partner Eduard) accused the Catholic Church of homophobia

Behind the critique of the gay lobby is a much deeper one. Men may truly believe in God but for most of them chastity is too big an ask and if enforced, leads, at worst, to abuse and at best to a clergy and hierarchy ignorant of, and often unsympathetic to, the problems of being human. From there it's but a skip and a jump to the role of women and their exclusion from the heart of the Church.

History again is the key. By denying the sacramental nature of the priesthood, the reformation gave women, potentially at least, a bigger voice. Even at its most conservative - think Victorian Anglicanism - the vicar's wife was still in his bed, mothering his children and shouldering parish duties, often specialising in compassion and charity. Thus when the second wave of feminism hit, hand in hand with gay politics, women had less distance to climb into the pulpit, though their ascent caused some Anglican minsters to convert to Catholicism, swelling the ranks of the conservatives.

464 gray line
More from the Magazine
Pope Francis

Is the Pope a communist? (June 2015)

Francis: The Pope's calling (October 2014)

464 gray line

Anyone under the age of 35 will have lived most of their adult life in a country with women priests. For the rest of us, any shock has long since disappeared. As too will the hoo-haa over women bishops. Whatever the difficulties, within Anglicanism the rise of women seems unstoppable. Within Catholicism it remains inconceivable.

So let's, just for the hell of it, allow our imaginations to run riot. What might a reformed Catholic Church look like? Start with small steps - allowing communion to divorced or co-habiting couples, the Church not judging gay men in loving relationships (both positions Francis himself has espoused). From there we move to a greater acceptance of homosexuality in general, even to same-sex union and families. How long before we hit celibacy and women priests? At which point there are women in the faith who would want to widen the debate, to suggest that it is the whole notion of an elevated priesthood and hierarchy that needs addressing, encouraging more democracy and community as a way to get better shepherds for the flock.

Enter a religion defined by God's mercy and inclusion, with a strong voice on issues like market excess and climate change and where men and women shared spiritual power. In a world under attack from testosterone-driven fundamentalism - I could have written exactly those same words before the events in Paris, but somehow they mean even more now - that is a religion even I might be tempted to join. Though how many Catholics I would find sitting next to me in the pews is a big question.

Inconceivable, clearly. In the real world, Francis' milder reforms have already hit a bedrock of opposition. Consider how little the recent family synod really moved its position on anything. Dragging one's heels is a powerful strategy used against a man who will be 80 next year.

Pope Francis in the popemobile What will Francis' legacy be?

But this Pope's legacy will be two-fold - what he can achieve in his lifetime and what will happen after him. I throw in a final card from history. Conclaves may be open to the word of God, but they are also about mathematics. And humble though he may be, Francis is not innumerate. In his appointment of new cardinals - nearly 40 over two years - he has turned his back on established career paths, favouring instead clerics from the developing world. Give him another four or five years and the make-up of the next conclave could be dramatically different. In which case his successor won't need the six mules loaded with silver with which Rodrigo Borgia bought off his chief rival in 1494.

If I was still a Catholic, that would be something to pray for.

A selection of your comments.

The corruption and degeneracy which you rightly condemn are admittedly part of the Church's history. However, you conveniently forget the legions of devoted men and women who throughout its history have lived chaste, devoted and compassionate lives of loving service - inspired by its teachings and institutions.

Elia Malgieri, New York, US

Pope Francis is wrestling with a bureaucracy that is fighting for its own survival. It will take him down before he makes any changes. The church leaders are survivors and are more interested in their own positions: their three meals a day, free TV in the evening, their prestige and power than any silly changes in dogma.

Jim Calvert, Penticon, Canada

I am 55, Catholic and female and I have recently decided enough is enough. I will not go back to the Catholic church until there are women priests, enforced celibacy is abolished, contraception is permitted and the church stops vilifying homosexuals and lesbians. I don't agree with the writer on one point, though; enforced celibacy does not lead to abuse, rather paedophiles have traditionally been attracted to the priesthood because priests were trusted around children

Eleanor Dent, Cardiff, UK

This writer, like so many who talk about how they think the Church needs the reforms she describes, clearly doesn't understand the Catholic faith. I'm sorry that when she was a teenager and questioning her faith, that she didn't have people who could answer her questions and explain to her the love, logic and beauty of the Church. I hope that she and others like her will take a look again. The answers are there and now that we have the internet, they are so much easier to find

Jessica Barton, Corvallis, Canada

Sarah Dunant does not speak for the majority of Catholics I'm sure. The Catholic Church has, in my 63 years, faced many and accepted some changes. It does not need to jump off the cliff of change to please those who don't get their own way!

Kathryn Hartwright, Devon, UK

The writer might have been a catholic by birth but was never a real catholic by faith. The writer's view of Christianity and Catholicism is a reflection of his weak understanding of the faith he claims to know and wished to change. Christianity is not about people and gatherings, rather it is about Christ, Bible and Christly values. Political correctness as championed by western media is not same as Christian values and both can never be same.

Tony Adosa

This is one of the most biased and spiteful articles I have read by a former catholic. She makes a lot of specious arguments based on cherry picked data, throws in a lot of myths and half-truths as if they are historical fact to spice up the article and hides her own hatred (or tries to) of the church under guise of a being a 'critic'.

Siby Jose

Send us your thoughts on this topic and we will publish a selection

A Point of View is broadcast on Friday on Radio 4 at 20:50 GMT and repeated on Sunday at 08:50 GMT. Catch up on BBC iPlayer

Subscribe to the BBC News Magazine's email newsletter to get articles sent to your inbox.

More on This Story